Outcome
In the end, I turned over several solutions and designs for them to build from. Also, after several "Going Big" designs for the card editor, he asked me to scale it back some, which came out to be the card editor that is used today. About six months after my contract ended, I checked in with their data analyst to see how much, if any, the new direction had impacted sales. He reported to me that the time spent selecting a card, designing it and checking out had dropped by 35% and sales were up by 10%.